We are greeted by a really nice main-cover by Walter Simonson and Laura Martin for UNCLE SCROOGE A CHRISTMAS CAROL #1 (Marvel Comics, Cover Date: January, 2027).
Uncle Scrooge McDuck is dressed as his namesake, Ebeneezer Scrooge, with Huey, Dewey, and Louie appearing as the three visiting ghosts. Nice as it is, the boys are NOT the aforementioned "three visiting ghosts" that appear in the interior story proper.
...Perhaps this was meant to be the cover of UNCLE SCROOGE ANOTHER CHRISTMAS CAROL? Or another "What If...?" special or sumpthin'? Anyway, I really like the cover, regardless of what it illustrates!
Opening the issue, we are met with a full-page of credits placed on page-one, more apropos to a big-budget feature film (...something Marvel knows quite a bit about) rather than a standard format comic book!
JUST LOOK AT THIS LIST OF CREDITS, WHY DON'TCHA? Twenty-three names, all done up in that too-close-for-coincidence, uniquely right-leaning (...NOT in the political sense) STAR TREK LOGO font!
Anyone and everyone involved with the production of this issue seems to be listed... save Charles Dickens himself!
Dickens, without whom there would be no story of "A Christmas Carol", no Uncle Scrooge McDuck for Carl Barks to create when inspired by that story (...which would not exist without Mr. Dickens), and this very comic would also not exist - likely to be replaced on the production schedule by just another title featuring one or more of the various "Spider-Men-Women-and-Children" type that proliferate in their many contemporary continuities!
I mean, I never liked it when Disney comic books listed NO credits... but SHEESH!
This adaptation of Dickens' "A Christmas Carol" (...of which there have been more than most anyone could count) is written by longtime comics writer Louise Simonson, whose work I've always admired, particularly so on her incredible run of the first 83 issues (!) of SUPERMAN: THE MAN OF STEEL (a title running 134 issues, 1991-2003), which took the series through the landmark "The Death of Superman", "Funeral for a Friend", and "Reign of the Supermen" mega story arc!
Our story finally opens on page-two with Scrooge all-atwitter over flying with his nephews to claim a solid gold asteroid - a voyage he plans for Christmas Day!
Golly, wouldn't his ownership of the "Twenty-Four Carat Moon" be enough galactic gold for anyone?
I won't fault Louise Simonson for not acknowledging, or at least not referencing, this because as a presumed perfectly "normal" human being, I can hardly expect her to have every known Uncle Scrooge story in her memory banks... as many of "us" do! Besides, the golden asteroid becomes an important plot point later in her story - No Spoilers!
However, as one of those not-quite-perfectly-"normal"-human-beings, I can save even this probable oversight for the rest of us not-quite-perfectly-"normal"-human-beings...
In the second issue of IDW's initially great UNCLE SCROOGE series, in the story "Meteor Rights", yours truly addressed the matter of Scrooge's twenty-four carat moon, and how owning it still kept him at only a slight lead over Flintheart Glomgold as "The Money Champ"!
Flinty keeps up with Scrooge in "Meteor Rites"!
So, relating that to Ms. Simonson's story, perhaps Scrooge desired a huge chunk of asteroid gold simply to, once again, build an insurmountable lead over Glomgold! ...Anyway, let's move on, lest we become even less perfectly-"normal"-human-beings...
When Donald and the boys balk at being Christmas no-shows at Grandma Duck's this year, Scrooge decides to go it alone. Note how Louise Simonson and/or the colorist gets Huey (red), Dewey (blue), and Louie (green) "right" cap-and-scarf-wise in this duckish debate! An easy thing for persons who are presumed perfectly "normal" human beings, unlike "us", to miss.
A great big coloring kudos to them!
Ludwig Von Drake (and not Louie) as the Ghost of Christmas Present...
And Gyro Gearloose (and not the mysterious black-clad specter who is, presumably, Dewey if the color-codings hold true) as the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come.
"Don Rosa-like Scrooge" shows "our" Scrooge some BEAUTIFULLY DRAWN AND COLORED visions of McDuck's early Klondike days, but seemingly miscasts Soapy Slick as a "villain TOO LAZY to seek an honest fortune" and who had cheated Scrooge at cards, stole his mule, and now plans to jump his claim! Far from the crooked businessman and usurer with a deep grudge against Scrooge, as previously depicted by Barks, Rosa, and Kari Korhonen! (see links to left)
Inaccurate, but beautiful nonetheless!
"Ludwig Von Drake" shows Scrooge (re)-visions of a recent adventure where, heedless to the cautioning of Donald and the boys, and expert-on-everything Ludwig Von Drake, Scrooge's unbridled lust for gold leads to his becoming a lifeless golden statue!
Not exactly new ground, previously explored in Barks' "The Fabulous Philosopher's Stone" (UNCLE SCROOGE [Dell] #10 1955)...
And even animated in the original DuckTales' final episode "The Golden Goose Part 2" (1990)!
Finally, Gyro Gearloose, as the hooded and eerily silent Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come, shows Scrooge what becomes of him and his ill-fated solo journey to his desired asteroid of solid gold!
It's a wee bit too much for him to handle alone, and there's a still bigger misfortune waiting for him when he finally sets (crashes, actually, and without Launchpad too) down upon the object of his gold-lust!
Um, "made it", Scrooge? Read UP one paragraph, okay? ...Er, ahem "still bigger misfortune waiting for him"? ..."Bigger misfortune"? Aw, skip it! When he gets this way, there's just no reasoning with him! Sigh!
Overall, this is a very good UNCLE SCROOGE STORY, in terms of both writing and art! Most importantly, it is truly an "UNCLE SCROOGE STORY" without that Marvel tinge - or overpowering flood tide, if you prefer - that can taint the story in the eyes of traditional Disney comics fans like "us"!
Marvel and Louise Simonson are to be commended for that!















































